|
Post by airraider on Feb 2, 2009 17:58:35 GMT -6
A good buddy of mine.. one who I used to coach for.. is in a situation that I would like your thoughts on..
He has had a great relationship with everyone, especially the principal.. this is his second year at the school..
He has a kid quit on him at the end of the season..
Said basically that he wants to play.. and would if he didn't have to do all the off season stuff.. whatever..
Well.. time for the football banquet to come around.. and his mom wants him to be able to go to it and be involved.
Well my buddy says no way.. the kid cannot go.. Doesn't feel it would be the best thing for the team for someone who quits to be recognized as apart of the team.
Well.. the principal gets involved and says the kid has to go..
So my buddy says that is fine.. and tonight as the banquet is going on.. he will be sitting at home..
The principal said he is going to have to write him up for it.. and my buddy said.. thats fine..
Several players also said they would not attend if the kid in question was allowed to go..
What are your thoughts on this?
I have mixed feelings.. but just wanted to see how others viewed this.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 2, 2009 18:05:40 GMT -6
pick and choose your battles. No way am i going to get a write up for a kid I'm not going to see again next season...who cares, let him hang out one last time with the team
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 2, 2009 18:11:50 GMT -6
While I agree with the coach's sentiments, I also agree with the "Pick your battles" line.
|
|
|
Post by airraider on Feb 2, 2009 18:13:12 GMT -6
pick and choose your battles. No way am i going to get a write up for a kid I'm not going to see again next season...who cares, let him hang out one last time with the team That is kind of my thoughts on this.. pick your battles.. dont make trouble over something so trivial.. but.. this guy is one of those bull headed guys.. will not bow down on anything.. if nothing else.. just so he can say he doesnt and hasnt backed down.. but to a point.. I can see where he is coming from.. This is the same guy who told the team that there will be NOOOO taking part in ANY foolishness the week of homecoming.. And of course.. the night before the game.. 3 seniors went along with some girls to hang a banner from the roof of the school.. some dumb arse let the door lock behind them.. and the fire department had to be called to come get them off the roof.. because the janitor and principal were both unable to be reached.. so.. the next night.. all 3 had to watch their senior year homecoming game from the stands..
|
|
|
Post by optionguy on Feb 2, 2009 18:31:32 GMT -6
A good buddy of mine.. one who I used to coach for.. is in a situation that I would like your thoughts on.. He has had a great relationship with everyone, especially the principal.. this is his second year at the school.. He has a kid quit on him at the end of the season..Said basically that he wants to play.. and would if he didn't have to do all the off season stuff.. whatever.. Well.. time for the football banquet to come around.. and his mom wants him to be able to go to it and be involved. Well my buddy says no way.. the kid cannot go.. Doesn't feel it would be the best thing for the team for someone who quits to be recognized as apart of the team. Well.. the principal gets involved and says the kid has to go.. So my buddy says that is fine.. and tonight as the banquet is going on.. he will be sitting at home.. The principal said he is going to have to write him up for it.. and my buddy said.. thats fine.. Several players also said they would not attend if the kid in question was allowed to go.. What are your thoughts on this? I have mixed feelings.. but just wanted to see how others viewed this. If the player completed the season (i.e., didn't quit before the season ended) then there is no legitimate reason that he cannot participate in the banquet. If he had quit or had been removed from the team prior to the end of the season then he should not be allowed to participate. I agree with the other posters--your friend needs to pick his battles.
|
|
|
Post by optionguy on Feb 2, 2009 18:35:36 GMT -6
pick and choose your battles. No way am i going to get a write up for a kid I'm not going to see again next season...who cares, let him hang out one last time with the team That is kind of my thoughts on this.. pick your battles.. dont make trouble over something so trivial.. but.. this guy is one of those bull headed guys.. will not bow down on anything.. if nothing else.. just so he can say he doesnt and hasnt backed down.. but to a point.. I can see where he is coming from.. This is the same guy who told the team that there will be NOOOO taking part in ANY foolishness the week of homecoming.. And of course.. the night before the game.. 3 seniors went along with some girls to hang a banner from the roof of the school.. some dumb arse let the door lock behind them.. and the fire department had to be called to come get them off the roof.. because the janitor and principal were both unable to be reached.. so.. the next night.. all 3 had to watch their senior year homecoming game from the stands.. They were lucky that they were not suspended from school and/or charged and/or dismissed from the team.
|
|
|
Post by jgordon1 on Feb 2, 2009 19:16:26 GMT -6
we were lucky.... had two kids kicked off the team. one of the parents called the principal and wanted kid to go to banquet. principal says he will get back to them, principal asks HC and HC says no. the principal backs him up. We are soooo lucky
|
|
|
Post by bigm0073 on Feb 2, 2009 19:41:17 GMT -6
That guy is a "spineless" principal and I agree with the coach... Nobody needs to deal with that garbage.
Hey you guys know how I feel... If the principal and AD do not support you, it is TIME TO GO!! I would have done the same thing and beieve me I would have been fine.
|
|
|
Post by coache67 on Feb 2, 2009 19:49:23 GMT -6
Just out of curiosity, what's up with the banquet being in Feb?
|
|
|
Post by airraider on Feb 2, 2009 20:18:40 GMT -6
Just out of curiosity, what's up with the banquet being in Feb? Not sure about the date.. By the way.. the principal.. his dad is the second most winningest coach in Louisiana history. I wonder how his dad would have acted in the same situation?
|
|
|
Post by khalfie on Feb 2, 2009 20:47:00 GMT -6
Real easy...
First, as everyone else has stated, pick your battles...
And the battle he should pick, is...
1. Allow the kid to attend... 2. Recognize all the other kids... for whatever... 3. Conveniently forget to recognize the kid. 4. Repeat for something else... 5. Smile and say good night,
|
|
coachgeorge51
Sophomore Member
Cliches and mottos is mindless verbal nonsense.
Posts: 151
|
Post by coachgeorge51 on Feb 2, 2009 22:06:57 GMT -6
No way should you have to back down to this crazy parent and a quitter for a kid. Never allow people like this to undermine you or what you are trying to do. If you don't get supported on this, when will you ever get supported?
I think this is not a "pick your battle", but a very important underlying message to you that you will not be supported when the sh** hits the fan. And, with any good coach, it should hit the fan or you probably aren't doing your job.
|
|
|
Post by coachjoe3 on Feb 3, 2009 0:49:11 GMT -6
I think taking the write up is the way to go. A coach sticks to his principles, even if it gets him fired . . .
. . . no matter what job you have, you're gonna go sometime. Might as well do it your way.
That's what I think anyway.
|
|
tedseay
Sophomore Member
Posts: 165
|
Post by tedseay on Feb 3, 2009 4:09:21 GMT -6
Real easy... First, as everyone else has stated, pick your battles... And the battle he should pick, is... 1. Allow the kid to attend... 2. Recognize all the other kids... for whatever... 3. Conveniently forget to recognize the kid. 4. Repeat for something else... 5. Smile and say good night, Here is wisdom. Me, I'd take the low road and prepare a monologue just for this kid and his idiot parents -- get out the Sam Kinnison collection as warm-up material... "I'd like to thank our sponsors for this evening, Gatorade -- the shizzle that just won't quizzle. "Speaking of Quisling, he was a Norwegian who betrayed his country to the Nazis -- that's right, this is someone who quit on HIS ENTIRE COUNTRY! "Oh OH OHHHH! D'ya think they have a picture of him hanging up at QUITTERS R US?" Scorched earth, baby...
|
|
|
Post by touchdownmaker on Feb 3, 2009 4:34:51 GMT -6
I think its important to "recognize" trouble maker kids at banquets. Its not that hard to do.
We call each kid up, say a number of really nice things about them and make them feel all warm and fuzzy. I never forget those kids and parents who made life miserable and strongly consider my words for those kids. Usually less is more. Call their name, say thank you for a great season, shake hands and move on to the next kid. continue with the warm fuzzies. You really cant say something and then take it back so be careful. better not to say much.
i had a similar situation a few years ago, kid quit, mom was a pain the rear all year anyhow, then they show to the banquet to pic up photos and team jacket. we gave it out but man it was tainted for them.
this situation isnt difficult at all, you make sure you have YOUR PLAYERS there first, you make sure YOU GO to protect YOUR JOB and YOUR PROGRAM and you allow this kid to come back out but you ride his butt all off season about all of the off season work required. make it clear, no lifitng, no playing time. I am going through this right now with a couple of quitters who want to come back. The kid who told me "I dont practice in august" so he can go to summer camp has a rude awakening when I refuse to give him gear in september. maybe I will instruct all of my staff to be "too busy" to hand out gear for a couple of weeks. lol- Ill remind his mom that we had equipment handouts already and now we all need our own personal time away from football and cant give that up for kids who didnt come to gear day. we certainly cant give up practice time, coach meeting time for one player.
these are hard lessons some folks have to learn. they cant have it both ways.
|
|
|
Post by airraider on Feb 3, 2009 6:18:34 GMT -6
I think the main thing is he and the kid ended the thing in a civil manner.. The kid wanted to just not go to save all teh problems.. it was the crazy mom who demanded that he be allowed to go.. and she would not let the kid get the refund on the 4 tickets the family had purchased.
|
|
|
Post by airraider on Feb 3, 2009 6:18:29 GMT -6
I think the main thing is he and the kid ended the thing in a civil manner.. The kid wanted to just not go to save all teh problems.. it was the crazy mom who demanded that he be allowed to go.. and she would not let the kid get the refund on the 4 tickets the family had purchased.
|
|
|
Post by olinecoach61 on Feb 3, 2009 6:32:54 GMT -6
I'd give a speech on loyalty and not being a quitter. That way everyone knows I'm addressing the situation but I'm not getting in trouble with the admins for not showing up.
|
|
|
Post by jpdaley25 on Feb 3, 2009 7:49:46 GMT -6
If the kid finished the season and then was man enough to tell the coach face to face that he wouldn't be back next season, I think that deserves at least a little respect on handling things in an open and honest way.
How many kids have you had that just quietly snuck away? How many kids have there been that you planned on being there, and then all of a sudden they weren't there?
If he finished the season, finished what he started, then I think he should have been allowed to go to the banquet. I wouldn't have wasted any time on him there, but I would have allowed it.
BUT,
If he quit before the season ended, there's no way in heaven or hell that I would have allowed him to come to the banquet, and if my principal tried to overrule that based on parental pressure, he wouldn't have to write me up, because I would already be gone.
No principal worth working for would force that onto a head football coach.
|
|
|
Post by bigm0073 on Feb 3, 2009 8:06:44 GMT -6
Man I am sorry I can believe what I am reading... What have we come to as a society...
I see this as black and white:
If he COMPLETED the season and came to the last week of practice/game but came to me after the season and said he can not do it, than I am ok with it... He completed his end, and will get recognized.. No problem.
But if he did not make it TO THE FINAL game - I am not budging... Sorry. Guys this is not pick your battle this is "You are working for a worthless administrator" and guess what, you will have more grief and problems to come....
Bottom line we as coaches "Control our own destiny" and if we have F-Faces for administrators it is time to move on...
My last job I was hired by probably the BEST PRINCIPAL ever.. He had been at the school for over 20 years. love Football and B-BALL (Never missed a game) ALWAYS supported coaches and teachers with parents... My first few years were Rocky (Threw off a kid in the middle of the season who verbally committed to UVA) made a TON of tough decisions... This guy ALWAYS had my back. When he hired my I asked for three things:
1. Let me teach Government ONLY - No two preps and not class that is tested by the state.
2. Last block off - That included NO duty (As football coaches our program is our duty).
3. Hire a guy to be my OC and Strength Coach for the open PE position...
He did all three..
By my fourth year we have a new lady and she takes away my lst block every other day and decides I need a duty for the 2nd semester.... OK - I See where this is going...
We play in the regional championship game on a Saturday and the following Friday I had a face to face meeting with the AD at my current school about the job... I was hired 3 weeks later...
Bottom line - That school was going down quick and the the new principal was not the one who hired me and had NO clue what I was doing... Me and six of my coaches left because the administration was all f uped.... I do not need that crap, not for what we do as coaches and the hours and time we put in... No way.
Believe Me - I would dig my heels in and take the letter... And if I did not like where this place was going I would not be with an administration that would not support a very simple and obvious decision.
Some might see this situation as trivial I see it as "Foreshadowing of problems down the road".....
|
|
|
Post by justryn2 on Feb 3, 2009 8:38:30 GMT -6
The key for me, as with others who have posted here, is did the kid complete the season? If he finished out the entire season then he should go to the banquet. But, if he left the team before the season was over then there is no way he should be allowed to attend. If you're not getting backing on this then it is probably time to move on.
|
|
pbids
Freshmen Member
Posts: 67
|
Post by pbids on Feb 3, 2009 8:55:24 GMT -6
The banquet is for the past season and the players that participated in it. If this particular player was involved in that season then he should be at the banquet, regardless of the bad blood created by him not coming back next season. Focus on this season only and just don't mention anything about next season for that kid when you talk about him. At our school, if he quit mid season he probably wouldn't even have known when the dinner was, but if he did he wouldn't be given tickets for it.
|
|
|
Post by red2slam on Feb 3, 2009 9:55:45 GMT -6
the minute the principle sticks his nose in my football program? Especially if I have had any previous success, one or 10 seasons, I starting shopping my services. Its a slippery slope to unemployment once the parents can dictate guidelines for participation and discipline.
|
|
coachgeorge51
Sophomore Member
Cliches and mottos is mindless verbal nonsense.
Posts: 151
|
Post by coachgeorge51 on Feb 3, 2009 9:58:32 GMT -6
He's a quitter! He gets absolutely no accolades or recognition for anything regarding the football program.
This is exactly how coaches lose the respect of the kids who are committed, care, and will help you build your program. We are in the business of getting the best out of kids, not accepting the worst - I, too, can't believe the state of our society right now - sad...........
But, remember to enjoy, respect, and always support all the wonderful kids that ARE doing it right because I know we each have them in our programs.
|
|
|
Post by red2slam on Feb 3, 2009 10:00:27 GMT -6
delete. wrong topic.
|
|
|
Post by schultbear74 on Feb 3, 2009 10:49:30 GMT -6
you guys make me proud to be a member of the coaching profession.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 3, 2009 12:56:24 GMT -6
[This is the same guy who told the team that there will be NOOOO taking part in ANY foolishness the week of homecoming.. [/quote]
Because god knows he never did anything silly when he was their age. I'm sure he had no part in that drinking, drugs and sex nonsense....right ? why doesn't he try to ban them from that while he's at it
Wow teenagers acting stupid, who ever heard of such a thing
Plus the kid didn't quit, he stuck out the season, and has decided not to return the next...I can see if the kid left mid season. It's his mom whos breaking balls about letting him go to the banquet.
|
|
|
Post by rip60zgo on Feb 3, 2009 14:52:50 GMT -6
Not a teacher so please forgive my ignorance, but what is so terrible about "being written up"? What goes on in this process? Is the entire situation detailed in the write up? If so, this could actually be construed as a positive when viewed by a better administrative group in the future, couldn't it? Is being written up like check marks next to your name on the blackboard, but for big boys and girls? Are you allowed to respond to the allegations/charges/write up, and is that also considered part of your file? I agree with the others who said if the kid finished, but is not playing next year, come on in. This is not "quitting" in the negative sense of the word in my mind. This is not that different than giving your 2-weeks notice. If he bailed mid-season, then I would have to be "written up" because he won't be at the banquet. "Being written up" just doesn't sound like such a horrible consequence to me, I guess.
Oh, and in regard to, "Do the right thing... no matter what??", that should be the goal always. Isn't this what we ask of our players?
|
|
|
Post by coachjoe3 on Feb 3, 2009 15:36:37 GMT -6
I'm a little confused now that I've read some of the other responses . . . did the kid quit after the season ended or at (towards?) the end of the season with some time left in his commitment? I might have misinterpreted what airraider wrote.
To me "Coach, I won't be coming back next year," after the season ended is different than "I quit" during the season, even with only a little time left . . .
If it's the first, I say it's okay to let him go. But if it's the second, I still say no way.
|
|
|
Post by coachjoe3 on Feb 3, 2009 15:44:00 GMT -6
bigm0073,
Loved your post, especially the bottom line for coaches controlling our own destiny.
|
|