|
Post by coachcalande on Nov 23, 2006 8:40:06 GMT -6
Ok veteran coaches, rookie coaches and all of you that just have an opinion... WHY DO SO MANY VARSITY COACHES RUN THINGS LIKE WEIGHT LIFTING COURSES, SPEED CAMPS, FLAG FOOTBALL LEAGUES, FOOTBALL YOUTH CLINICS AND THE LIKE...BUT CHARGE THE VERY KIDS THAT WILL BE COMING THRU THEIR PROGRAMS?seems like a conflict of interest to me. i just want to understand the thinking and rationale behind it. thanks and you wont get an arguement from me...just tell me why you charge or why someone you know charges so I can understand it. thanks again.
|
|
|
Post by blb on Nov 23, 2006 9:03:25 GMT -6
The short answer is my assistants and I are a professional people and our time and expertise are worth something.
We charge our kids only for our summer camp (not all the other things you listed), which BTW according to state rules cannot be limited to students from our school. It is run through Community Ed (also per state rules) and they charge us for the privilege.
In exchange, kids get coached, a T-shirt, and three really good lunches served by our Touchdown Club.
25 years ago we had kids going to college camps (Michigan, etc.) paying $300+, most of which went to their assistant coaches as an additional stipend (college salaries weren't then what they are today). But the kids would not be running our "stuff," spent half the day conditioning, there was very little individual attention (unless you were a stud recruit) because of the number of campers, and some even got hurt because there was some contact.
So a few of us in our area with similar philosophies decided to start our own camp, where kids would be practicing our plays and techniques, not missing game time because they got injured, and not paying exorbitant fees to lift weights or run sprints (which obviously they can do for free at our own schools)! And us poor HS slobs who were making even less than the college guys could make a few bucks, too - not nearly what the big timers were of course, because we charged a fraction of what they were.
I write in the past tense, but the situation is still pretty much the same today as far as I can tell.
|
|
|
Post by wildcat on Nov 23, 2006 9:25:58 GMT -6
We don't charge the kids for the weightroom, but the school does pay the coaches to supervise.
We charge the kids $30 for our 4-day camp. They get a t-shirt and the rest of the money goes to pay the coaches (about $20 a day per coach).
When I was a young buck, I thought it was wrong for coaches to make money off of an activity that kids are essentially required to do. However, I have learned over the years that paying coaches for their time is the norm and is a great way for the head coach to show his assistants a little appreciation for their time.
If there is anything left over after paying for t-shirts and paying the coaches, the rest goes into an account that we can use to buy the kids pizza, pay for blank DVDs so the kikds have a copy of the scouting report, and other stuff like that.
|
|
|
Post by brophy on Nov 23, 2006 9:35:32 GMT -6
it was part of our fund-raising program at my last stop.
If you are giving something of value, you should be compensated for it. Also, it requires the parents to be accountable (if it's free, you are more inclined as a parent to not take it so seriously).
Every camp we do comes with T-shirts, pictures,and popsicles / drinks....pretty much the same as wildcat.
Also, where we were located, we COULDN'T have 'contact' with the kids UNLESS it was in a designated 'clinic' or 'camp'....this was one of the way we got around state regulations.
Guys that couldn't pay....we always got them 'scholarships'
But you think about it, Band kids have all the money, the athletes usually don't.
|
|
|
Post by djwesp on Nov 23, 2006 9:37:20 GMT -6
The hardest working kids that come out of our program are almost always the poorest.
The kid from the hills, who has worked hard all of his life, football being one of the only things he has.
You can go all the way from 7th grade in our program and never pay a dime. This may offer our students less services (we don't think so). But our program offers everything for free, because we thrive on those kids that football is one of the only things they have.
You need to spend more time with your boosters and the school board if you are in such financial distress you can't pay for a t-shirt.
|
|
|
Post by khalfie on Nov 23, 2006 10:01:08 GMT -6
I think there's a little more committment, when mom and dad have to come up with some pennies...
But I do believe no kid should be turned away... we call it a scholarship program, and the kid has to do a little work on the side for the program, with no one being the wiser.
|
|
coachf
Freshmen Member
Posts: 15
|
Post by coachf on Nov 23, 2006 10:15:15 GMT -6
We ask for money, mostly to raise some funds. We are way behind the times and the school does not provide for much in the budget. We only charge for camp and we give them a T-shirt and shorts. If they can't afford it, they can still come. They just don't get a t-shirt or shorts.
We basically have to raise funds however we can and in a small town you really have to rely on the parents.
|
|
|
Post by wildcat on Nov 23, 2006 10:32:58 GMT -6
Like Khalfie and Brophy, no kid has EVER missed anything because they couldn't pay. We have our share of kids who come from families that don't have much. These kids ALWAYS are welcome, whether they can pay or not.
|
|
|
Post by djwesp on Nov 23, 2006 10:59:03 GMT -6
My only problem with this is...
You guys are either.
1. Not giving the kid the materials from your camp. (which automatically singles him out)
2. Or having him or his parents approach you about not being able to afford something (which automatically singles him out).
How many people walk away from your program, rather than facing the reality of not being able to pay for these things. Maybe you are in a richer part of the country, but 10-15 bucks for a shirt is a lot for some of my kids. (30 bucks for a camp is clothes off some of our kids backs) Their parents work hard, and don't like to accept hand outs, and we definitely wouldn't expect them to come to us telling us that.
Your community is probably a lot different than ours. But we have plenty of kids that take pride in how hard their parents work (even if they don't have too dimes to rub together) and such things aren't compliments, they are humiliating.
If it works for your program, more power to you. There is a reason why we all don't do it the same, because where you live has a lot to do with it.
(over 50% of our team is on free and reduced lunches)
|
|
|
Post by blb on Nov 23, 2006 11:19:29 GMT -6
Our state rules do not allow for "scholarships" or even reduced rates.
Out of the campers' fee we pay Community Ed ($15 a kid) for sponsoring the camp, buy the food for three days of lunches, T-shirts, pay the coaches (about $5 each per player), and I take $10 per player and put it into our fund raiser account (as someone else stated). The money we charge our kids ensures a positive experience and is a huge bargain compared to what they would pay to go to a college camp, so I don't feel in the least bit guilty about it or that there is a "conflict of interest."
As someone also mentioned earlier, this is a good way to show appreciation to our assistant coaches with a little extra coin, and I treat it as such when determining camp salaries.
We do have a Youth Camp that is run by our Elementary AD with help from our varsity players. The proceeds from that go to fund our 6th-7th grade teams, which are not school sponsored. He also runs a 4th-5th grade Flag Football program. We have put on a free youth clinic in the past but scheduling has precluded that recently.
Our AD brings in an "expert" to run a Speed Camp open to all area athletes the first week school is out that there is a charge for.
We have conditioning workouts (separate varsity, JV, and freshmen) three days a week in the summer but receive no additional compensation for that.
|
|
|
Post by brophy on Nov 23, 2006 11:21:16 GMT -6
How many people walk away from your program, rather than facing the reality of not being able to pay for these things. none. We're not turning anyone away - and I don't believe anyone else is either. But then again, if we had sugar daddies in administration or boosters, we could get away without charging. Half the time, I think parents like the camps because it is a cheap form of 'baby-sitting' for them We normally don't give out shorts & shirts until the completion of the camp, anyway..... 1) because they usually don't get in until then (lol) 2) because those low-income kids usually wait until the last day of camp to pay 3) because it is a reward for 'surviving' the duration of the camp How fair is it for us to do fund-raising and some kids don't pull their weight in sales? Is it not fair for their own actions to single them out? Do I like fund-raising? It is the worst thing to do short of dealing with know-it-all parents....but if it doesn't come from the Admin or boosters...it's gotta come from somewhere.
|
|
|
Post by sls on Nov 23, 2006 11:42:57 GMT -6
I think parents like the camps because it is a cheap form of 'baby-sitting' for them I have a youth camp in May from 3:00 to 5:00PM Monday thruough Thursday. Give awards for punt pass kick contest at the end of the week and dialy prizes for attitude. We alos supply teeshirts and snacks. We charge $20.00 per kid and it has went from 6 in 03 to 90 kids last year. I agree with Brophy, it is cheap babysitting.
|
|
|
Post by sls on Nov 23, 2006 11:44:17 GMT -6
Who charges for practice packs?
How much and what do you give?
|
|
|
Post by blb on Nov 23, 2006 11:58:16 GMT -6
We don't charge per se. Kids bring in $50 or more for our Lift-a-Thon fund raiser get T-shirt and shorts ($100-plus they get T-shirt, shorts, and sweat shirt, or polo shirt, or whatever we decide to give away that year).
|
|
|
Post by wildcat on Nov 23, 2006 13:34:50 GMT -6
My only problem with this is... You guys are either. 1. Not giving the kid the materials from your camp. (which automatically singles him out) 2. Or having him or his parents approach you about not being able to afford something (which automatically singles him out). Shows how little you know! Like I said, no kid is EVER turned away...our community is SMALL. We do football camp in July, but the signup is in May. So, we know, WELL IN ADVANCE, which kids are not coming to camp. When we realize that a kid who "should be there" hasn't turned in their camp form, we talk to those kids and try to find out why they aren't coming. It is usually evident if the reason is financial. If it comes out that the reason is financial, we don't even mention money. We just call the parents and tell them that we expect Little Johnny to be at camp. In every case I can think of, those kids are at camp. How many people walk away from your program, rather than facing the reality of not being able to pay for these things. Maybe you are in a richer part of the country, but 10-15 bucks for a shirt is a lot for some of my kids. (30 bucks for a camp is clothes off some of our kids backs) Their parents work hard, and don't like to accept hand outs, and we definitely wouldn't expect them to come to us telling us that. You are being ridiculous. Where are you coaching football? Tennessee during the Great Depression or something? How many of your kids who can't come up with $30 for football camp have Ipods, Playstations, satellite TV, and $75 shoes? The simple fact is that it is a matter of priorities. There is a big difference between being from a working poor family and living in poverty. Your community is probably a lot different than ours. But we have plenty of kids that take pride in how hard their parents work (even if they don't have too dimes to rub together) and such things aren't compliments, they are humiliating. I doubt it. Kids are kids, no matter where you are, although, in your case, the kids who live in your community must be invalids or mentally challenged if they can't mow a few lawns or flip a couple of burgers to make $30 to go to football camp. If it works for your program, more power to you. There is a reason why we all don't do it the same, because where you live has a lot to do with it. (over 50% of our team is on free and reduced lunches) Cute. You spend 95% of your post ripping on coaches who charge for camps and then you try a little "but it's cool if you guys do it" at the end. Just curious, but in what state do you coach and how many state championships have your teams won?
|
|
|
Post by fbdoc on Nov 23, 2006 14:03:08 GMT -6
We don't charge our HS kids for summer conditioning but one of the best things we have come across is our Jr. Crusader program which we run each Spring for our elementary kids. These are one week sessions from 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM Monday through Friday. We have 2 sessions that last one week. The first one is for K, 1st, and 2nd graders, then we do another week for our 3rd, 4th, and 5th graders. We charge the kids $50 for the week and they get a t-shirt with our football logo on it. The kids have a great time and the parents love it! We can't pay for better publicity for our program than having parents watch their kids having a great time with our varsity players and coaches working with them. It also allows us to make a few bucks.
We collect all of the kids after school and start in the gym. We spend a few minutes stretching and running (basically a short version of our own warmups) and then go outside. I have about 8-10 players who help. We set up 6 stations and have the little kids rotate through each one. We do passing, catching, running backs, o-line, tackling (form tackle on the dummies), and kicking. All the kids get to do each skill. The final 10-15 minutes we split the kids up and play touch football with our HS players working as coaches. The 90 minutes goes very fast!
|
|
|
Post by djwesp on Nov 23, 2006 14:07:19 GMT -6
We don't charge our HS kids for summer conditioning but one of the best things we have come across is our Jr. Crusader program which we run each Spring for our elementary kids. These are one week sessions from 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM Monday through Friday. We have 2 sessions that last one week. The first one is for K, 1st, and 2nd graders, then we do another week for our 3rd, 4th, and 5th graders. We charge the kids $50 for the week and they get a t-shirt with our football logo on it. The kids have a great time and the parents love it! We can't pay for better publicity for our program than having parents watch their kids having a great time with our varsity players and coaches working with them. It also allows us to make a few bucks. We collect all of the kids after school and start in the gym. We spend a few minutes stretching and running (basically a short version of our own warmups) and then go outside. I have about 8-10 players who help. We set up 6 stations and have the little kids rotate through each one. We do passing, catching, running backs, o-line, tackling (form tackle on the dummies), and kicking. All the kids get to do each skill. The final 10-15 minutes we split the kids up and play touch football with our HS players working as coaches. The 90 minutes goes very fast! This makes me wonder. Does anyone have the High School team sponsor your youth football championship? And how do you break up the real young ones fbdoc, do you just keep them all together?
|
|
|
Post by saintrad on Nov 23, 2006 14:29:21 GMT -6
coaching on the Navajo reservation, I can understand the dilemma of not having money... Mom and/or Dad or alcoholics, out of work, or just plain not there and the kid is dealing with having to be in school, take care of his family, AND is trying to do something they love...football, all while trying to be a student first. It is hard. But I also see those players that have the newest Ipods and shoes and say they they dont have it. Its all about individual circumstances and such. I dont go in for those that get all righteous about it when they dont have to deal with it everyday. My wife and I buy extra groceries to help some of my students that cant even afford laundry soap or wahtever. we do it because it is the right thing to do, not because we are obligated or feel we need to save them. Some of these players/students/kids are in abject poverty and yes it may be a hardship to get an extra $30 for a camp, but we find ways to makes sure they aren't singled out for being poor or having to take care of their families. We just find a way to give our players a way of feeling as a part of something bigger than themselves
|
|
|
Post by coachwilk on Nov 23, 2006 18:58:30 GMT -6
When we have players who cannot afford it, or players we know will have trouble paying for camp, we have them work at our youth camp and pay for them to work it out of the youth camp money. That way we know they have the money for our camp and can get the few things they need to pay for (practice jersey, t-shirts, ect...) Seems to be a nice way to help them out so they have the opportunity to be in camp and get what they need with out being singled out.
|
|
|
Post by blackfly73 on Nov 23, 2006 19:20:48 GMT -6
Chris;
MANY of the kids at my former school would fall into that category. They simply can't cough up the dough to pay for things, and most DON'T have iPODS, or the money they do have MUST go towards new shoes, or clothes.
Your right it is priorities... and when it comes to pay bills (some of our kids work jobs to HELP pay bills), or provide clothing... those things take priorities away from football fees.
Just because someone has a cell phone, does not mean they are not poor. In fact a cell phone, pay-as-you-go, is often the ONLY phone a very poor family has - they end up being cheaper than a 'land' line. That is a FACT.
I can recall we had a number of kids who had about 2-5 shirt and 1-2 pairs of pants. They weren't in 'poverty' but they were poor. I've also coached a kid who was homeless, and would spend the odd night on the streets.
We've talked before... the program I was formerly in has won about 15 championsips in 20 years, and we now have alumni in the NFL.
I don't like charging kids in my program unless I HAVE to... It gets ridiculous if a kid pays a bunch for football... then pays a ton for basketball. Add a family in with 2-3 kids... and it DOES get tight in the purse-strings.
|
|
coachf
Freshmen Member
Posts: 15
|
Post by coachf on Nov 23, 2006 23:16:00 GMT -6
I don't understand why this is an issue. Seriously, if you have been running camp, weights, lift-a-thons, etc. for years and have been successful, then why should you have to be made to feel guilty. It is an "holier than thou," type of attitude.
There are always going to be coaches who try to make a buck off of everything and screw their kids over. However, 98% of them would never do that. And I am sure most of the coaches on here evaluate what they are planning on running for money. If parents/players did not think they were getting their money's worth, they wouldn't pay for it. PERIOD. Not every school has a big budget to play with. We have things to buy and nothing to do it with.
I can't even begin to think of how much money I have spent for my football teams. I have spent more than I really am able to. I have debt that I should have paid off, instead of buying the extra footballs we need for practice, the supplies for the games, the gas for travel. I have done this because I love the kids and football. I will spend the money, even if it means that I will have a tight budget that month, because I want to see the kids succeed. I know that as a parent, I would do the same for my son, (soon to be sons. I would be willing to chip in (just like my parents), even if it meant that I was going to have to beat a check that month. Do not act like the parents and players are so downtrodden over this. My Dad still comments to me that he doesn't regret driving us miles and miles to and from practices. He doesn't regret that we ran low on money, because I needed shoes. He looks at those things with pride. He is filled with joy because he put himself secondary to our needs as his children. Was it easy, no. But it was satisfying.
As for giving the kids scholarships,etc. I am a little hesitant on that. I know that as HC I am responsible for running our fundraiser and buying our equipment/supplies. I take into account that we have several poor kids in our town. I know that some kids do not have the means to afford things. I know some of them do not want everyone else to know that they can't pay or participate. But, that is why I have an office/classroom where the kids can come in and talk privately. I normally, offer them a way to cover their end of the bargain (do some work/etc. if they want the t-shirt, shorts, whatever). I can't change their situation. I think that despite their being poor, they need to work for their scholarship, not get it for free.
We too often look at kids who are poor and we take pity on them. We just say, "Here, have the stuff. I know you can't afford it." But, what does that do for them. It gives them something for free and it includes them in the team, that's it. But, what about empowering them to change their situation. Teach them that they can be more than just a poor kid who can't afford a camp. Show them how to earn something. If we just give them handouts, they will sit there and wait for more. It is a disservice to bend the rules for them. Feeling sorry for them does not change their situation. Stand up and make them deliver. THAT is what will help them.
I think I have talked to much. Plus, my soapbox is starting to cave in.
|
|
|
Post by saintrad on Nov 24, 2006 0:24:02 GMT -6
i appreciate you and your soap box coachf...we need more people like you in this world.
|
|
|
Post by tvt50 on Nov 24, 2006 8:33:38 GMT -6
ANSWER- Because they are LOSERS and want to make a buck. Pay me with championships and with knowing that you will become a good man.
|
|
|
Post by Coach Huey on Nov 24, 2006 9:59:51 GMT -6
some states (leagues) may require a nominal fee for players to attend a camp or summer training session being conducted by members or their school. i agree with whoever said it earlier .... let's kill the "holier than thou" attitude of our posts (regardless of which side of the arguement you're on)
|
|
|
Post by saintrad on Nov 24, 2006 10:39:38 GMT -6
thank you huey
|
|
|
Post by wildcat on Nov 24, 2006 11:24:24 GMT -6
ANSWER- Because they are LOSERS and want to make a buck. Pay me with championships and with knowing that you will become a good man. So I am a loser for charging kids $30 for football camp? Just want to make sure I understand correctly.
|
|
|
Post by tog on Nov 24, 2006 11:45:39 GMT -6
some states (leagues) may require a nominal fee for players to attend a camp or summer training session being conducted by members or their school. i agree with whoever said it earlier .... let's kill the "holier than thou" attitude of our posts (regardless of which side of the arguement you're on)
|
|
|
Post by coachjd on Nov 24, 2006 12:18:30 GMT -6
We used to charge our kids when we did our own camps, but most of the money went back into the program fund to purchase things for the kids. ie. new weight equipment, new agility bags, pre-game meals, $$$ to pay the difference for a charter bus rather than a school bus.
Each coach who worked the camp would get more coaches gear rather than paying them cash. I think they enjoyed that more than the 25.00 or 30.00 they would get for working 3 days of camps.
|
|