|
Post by wingt74 on Mar 16, 2010 7:41:06 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by outlawjoseywales on Mar 16, 2010 9:19:22 GMT -6
Thanks for posting this. Although it isn't football, it is relevent. Most of us have adopted the idea of not doing "drills for drill sake" long ago. Good to see this with kids that actually have to go in harm's way. My mind and heart is with the young men and women who are fighting for us in forgein lands. One thing that surprised me, and I know that I'm from an old and alien time period. But, "Most of these soldiers have never been in a fistfight or any kind of a physical confrontation. They are stunned when they get smacked in the face," said Capt. Scott Sewell." Being raised in the rural south, I have to tell you that even my little wife had "physical confrontations" while in school. I had "physical confrontations" we called them fights in those days, all not connected to sports at all. Just a couple of big mouths roughing each other up. We all know what it feels like "getting smacked in the face." You learn things, like-don't hit a kid in the head, it hurts your hand. It's different now, it's much more dangerous. Now-a-days, kids shoot each other with alarming regularity, it's a different world now. You don't have brawls at PE, you have gangs killing each other. Bad stuff for sure, it's a different world for sure. I also don't think that schools should be blamed for the lack of physical fitness. It's sociatal. We rode bikes for hours, wrestled, played in the yard, built forts in the woods. Kids don't do that now, you cannot afford to not know where your kid is for hours anymore. Video games keeps the kids inside where they are safe and you can keep an eye on them. So, blaming schools for lack of PE, makes an easy target, but I disagree. It's just a different world. We have to know where our kids are 100% of the time now, you can't let your kid ride bikes all over town for hours, too dangerous. OJW
|
|
|
Post by phantom on Mar 16, 2010 9:38:29 GMT -6
They'll never make it without monkey rolls.
|
|
|
Post by morris on Mar 16, 2010 9:41:59 GMT -6
If you need a few good laughes look through the comment section. Some of the things people say that they honestly believe cracks me up. Like the guy asking about how good all that cardio is going to do them when they are in a fight because we all know no fighters ever do cardio.
|
|
|
Post by coachks on Mar 16, 2010 13:53:23 GMT -6
Thanks for posting this. Although it isn't football, it is relevent. Most of us have adopted the idea of not doing "drills for drill sake" long ago. Good to see this with kids that actually have to go in harm's way. My mind and heart is with the young men and women who are fighting for us in forgein lands. One thing that surprised me, and I know that I'm from an old and alien time period. But, "Most of these soldiers have never been in a fistfight or any kind of a physical confrontation. They are stunned when they get smacked in the face," said Capt. Scott Sewell." Being raised in the rural south, I have to tell you that even my little wife had "physical confrontations" while in school. I had "physical confrontations" we called them fights in those days, all not connected to sports at all. Just a couple of big mouths roughing each other up. We all know what it feels like "getting smacked in the face." You learn things, like-don't hit a kid in the head, it hurts your hand. It's different now, it's much more dangerous. Now-a-days, kids shoot each other with alarming regularity, it's a different world now. You don't have brawls at PE, you have gangs killing each other. Bad stuff for sure, it's a different world for sure. I also don't think that schools should be blamed for the lack of physical fitness. It's sociatal. We rode bikes for hours, wrestled, played in the yard, built forts in the woods. Kids don't do that now, you cannot afford to not know where your kid is for hours anymore. Video games keeps the kids inside where they are safe and you can keep an eye on them. So, blaming schools for lack of PE, makes an easy target, but I disagree. It's just a different world. We have to know where our kids are 100% of the time now, you can't let your kid ride bikes all over town for hours, too dangerous. OJW Too piggy back on this a bit.... I think a bigger issue, for me atleast growing up, was the constant threat of lawsuits. You play tackle football, some angry mom comes running down threatening to sue parents if their kid gets hurt. You wrestle around, parents threaten to sue over a black eye. We wern't allowed to play Red Rover because it was too dangerous. A lot of people label my generation (and the ones coming up) as lazy because we didn't play outside. {censored}. I wanted to play outside, but nobody would let me. Couldn't play baseball without helmets, can't play tackle football, Basketball sucks when your 10 and nobody can shoot, definately can't play hockey (too physical, too dangerous in the street and too expensive). What the hell were we supposed to play?
|
|
|
Post by airman on Mar 16, 2010 15:33:32 GMT -6
One thing I will say about generation Y and the next generation is how kids lives are scheduled for them. everything is organized for him. you get a group of 10 yr olds today and tell them to go play outside and they do not know how to choose teams or play w/o parents. it is sad.
When the USSR was still one unified state their military trained much like the article was talking. they used 53 and 70 lb kettle-bells to develop overall body strength. if you are not using kettle bells for fitness U R foolish I think. the bulgarians uses bulgarian sandbags which they made from rubber tire inner tubs, twist ties, sand and duct tape.
one thing the USMC has done for years is take 50 cal can, fill them with cement or sand and have the recruit do step ups with them. it simulates walking a long distance with weight.
|
|
|
Post by blb on Mar 16, 2010 15:39:44 GMT -6
One thing I will say about generation Y and the next generation is how kids lives are scheduled for them. everything is organized for him. you get a group of 10 yr olds today and tell them to go play outside and they do not know how to choose teams or play w/o parents. it is sad. When the USSR was still one unified state their military trained much like the article was talking. they used 53 and 70 lb kettle-bells to develop overall body strength. if you are not using kettle bells for fitness U R foolish I think. the bulgarians uses bulgarian sandbags which they made from rubber tire inner tubs, twist ties, sand and duct tape. one thing the USMC has done for years is take 50 cal can, fill them with cement or sand and have the recruit do step ups with them. it simulates walking a long distance with weight. air, you're not suggesting we start taking training lessons now from the LOSERS ('80s Afghanistan, 'Cold War')?! Also - somewhere in US or our territories-protectarates we've got to have enough sand for troops to simulate walking in, don't we?
|
|
|
Post by airmale on Mar 16, 2010 15:50:13 GMT -6
I just bought my first house. 1st weekend told my kids to go outside in the backyard and play. Looked out 15 minutes later and they were just staring at each other. They literally didn't know what to do. It was hilarious.
Recently was explaining play to a student. He couldn't understand you could play. He kept asking Play What? I sarcasticaly said you can put down the game controller and go outside. He never got it.
|
|
|
Post by airman on Mar 16, 2010 16:08:11 GMT -6
One thing I will say about generation Y and the next generation is how kids lives are scheduled for them. everything is organized for him. you get a group of 10 yr olds today and tell them to go play outside and they do not know how to choose teams or play w/o parents. it is sad. When the USSR was still one unified state their military trained much like the article was talking. they used 53 and 70 lb kettle-bells to develop overall body strength. if you are not using kettle bells for fitness U R foolish I think. the bulgarians uses bulgarian sandbags which they made from rubber tire inner tubs, twist ties, sand and duct tape. one thing the USMC has done for years is take 50 cal can, fill them with cement or sand and have the recruit do step ups with them. it simulates walking a long distance with weight. air, you're not suggesting we start taking training lessons now from the LOSERS ('80s Afghanistan, 'Cold War')?! it is already happening. Pavel Tsatsouline in already working with US special forces, SWAT, Fire Departments and police departments. Pavel was a form USSR special forces operator and trainer. he now lives in the states splitting his time between St. Paul Mn and California. Personally I wish the cold war was still going strong. U C, back in the cold war days everyone had to pick a side. all these little piss ant dictators and terrorists have come about because of the cold war ending. No longer do they have to face the freedom loving countries b/c they have all split. Europe no longer has a threat in their backyard so they no want to compete against the US. The former French President Jacque Charock(sp) wanted Europe to rival the US for power. PersonallY I think the US should leave NATO. The French, Germans, Dutch, Belgians all condemn the US for its military spending, while simultaneously cutting their own military spending because they know by treaty the US is obligated to defend them. That couple with the fact the US employs 80,000 German at just one air base is the only reason they like us. if the US withdrew from germany unemployment would sky rocket. however there will be a day when this dream of mine comes true because the US economy is about ready to collapse within the decade. all these freedom fighters(aka thugs wanta bes) came about because the USSR was in desperate financial struggles. what did the soviets have to sell, lots of tanks and AKS. look around the globe at the hot spots and what weapon do you c them all carrying ? The AK because it is cheap to buy. still, the russians r so far ahead of us when it comes to training. they kick our butt in weight lifting, wrestling, may of the field events. heck when is the last time the us medaled in the hammer throw. the only lesson we can learn from those losers as you put it is, do not depend on a military industrial complex for the majority of your jobs. I think we are going to lose in Afghanistan and Iraq myself. you cannot give freedom to people they have to want it for themselves. this and the fact they are an inferior group of people in the middle east is why. Lawrence of Arabia told the middle easterners you will be little people in the world because you focus on little things like being mad at so and so because he hit your great, great grandfather with a rock in the 19th century.
|
|
|
Post by airman on Mar 16, 2010 16:11:53 GMT -6
One thing I will say about generation Y and the next generation is how kids lives are scheduled for them. everything is organized for him. you get a group of 10 yr olds today and tell them to go play outside and they do not know how to choose teams or play w/o parents. it is sad. When the USSR was still one unified state their military trained much like the article was talking. they used 53 and 70 lb kettle-bells to develop overall body strength. if you are not using kettle bells for fitness U R foolish I think. the bulgarians uses bulgarian sandbags which they made from rubber tire inner tubs, twist ties, sand and duct tape. one thing the USMC has done for years is take 50 cal can, fill them with cement or sand and have the recruit do step ups with them. it simulates walking a long distance with weight. air, you're not suggesting we start taking training lessons now from the LOSERS ('80s Afghanistan, 'Cold War')?! Also - somewhere in US or our territories-protectarates we've got to have enough sand for troops to simulate walking in, don't we? out in 29 palms their is a town build just for urban warfare. it is out in the dessert. you are going to chuckle but the EOD guys(hurt locker) walk around in their suits. the suits weigh 80 lbs. a guy just recently ran a 10 k in one. he averaged 8.5 min miles
|
|
|
Post by tiger46 on Mar 17, 2010 0:42:59 GMT -6
I know this is going to sound a bit weird. But, as a former soldier (late 80's; some of the last of the Cold War Era soldiers) I find the article a bit disappointing. All of this so-called 'new training' was taught to us. My question would be, "When did it stop being taught"? I went through basic training at Ft. Bliss, El Paso, Tx. We did some of the standard drills talked about in this article. But, we also had to do sprints, lift and carry each other for 100yrds, etc... I didn't even know what a piloti was until I joined the Army. And, there were many days that I wished that I had never found out what they were, either. We did aerobic exercises. Please don't think of that crap you see on TV done by Richard Simmons and a squad of obese people. We did advanced aerobics taught by a certified professional. She- yes, she- used to reduce some soldiers to near tears. Also part of basic training at Bliss was two weeks of desert training. We were put through all kinds of hell out there- including hill assaults, marches, etc... wearing full MOPP gear. As far as BUFFs (Big Ugly Fat *uckers) went, they were put on strict diets, put on road guard duty during marches and made to do way more exercise. I can't think of any one of them that didn't have to go get their BDUs exchanged for smaller ones outside of two weeks. I never had to go into combat. So, I don't want to seem like I'm second-guessing a combat veteran. But, I think the guy may be missing the point behind bayonet drills. Something like less than 2% of combat kills are made with bayonets, iirc. But, part of bayonet training is to psychologically prepare you to kill someone at close quarters- same as hand-to-hand combat. Our Drill Sgts. referred to it as 'cold steel & close quarters' and/or 'being down to brass balls & bayonets'.I can understand his point if bayonets no longer easily fit on soldiers' weapons anymore. But, bayonets fit just fine on the M16 that we carried. And, it would have taken nothing short of killing us to get one of us to surrender it.
|
|
|
Post by davecisar on Mar 17, 2010 5:53:00 GMT -6
I went through basic at Ft Jackson in 1980 Some of my buddies that had gone through said "You will be in the best shape of your life" after basic, lose weight etc- They werent football players I went in with a wrestler buddy I had been raised on old school football, until college, no water, tons of real tough conditioning- Even at the youth level, real tough practices 6 days a week games on day 7 etc Hills, long distance runs, lots of sprints and old school drills- bull in ring (None of what we do now) Neither of us thought basic was a big deal. The runs, PT, marches etc rarely got me breathing very hard Uncomfortable, aggravating etc but not super tough and this was in South Carolina in June. What got most of the guys in my platoon was the mental strain. The heavy guys lost a TON of weight remarkable, non physical kids- smokers really suffered I actually gained weight, all you can eat 3 times a day-I had been living on my own getting up at 4:00 am to go to work, then school, then football The net: football was a great training ground mentally and physically, my wrestler buddy- same deal, neither of us thought it was a big deal. While I disliked it, it was a very good experience. I wasnt in the best shape of my life, but my guess is 95% of the guys were after 9 weeks of that. Back to the thread- we changed what we do on the practice field to reflect what we are trying to accomplish. I did away with almost all of the conditioning, cals and drills I did as a kid and in HS- we dont do anything because it has always been done.
On a bit of a different tangent- worked in a meat packing plant for 18 months in college. Started off with a "training group" of 16 people, by the end of week 2 there were only 2 of us left. I think it was football that prepared me to gut out those first 2 weeks.
|
|
|
Post by illiniwek on Mar 23, 2010 20:26:23 GMT -6
Good article. Interesting point Dave about the mental strain of basic training being tougher for some guys to handle than the physical strain. As a coach and just a casual observer of people, I always wonder what makes some people crack under stress, while others survive and sometimes even thrive.
|
|